Our Cafe

For over 10 years, we've been serving the community with fresh baked bagels, gourmet cream cheeses, sandwiches, & speciality coffees & teas. Our bagels are hand made from scratch using the highest quality ingredients & served fresh to you every morning. We offer a full service deli featuring Boar's Head products, home made salads, paninis, wraps & heroes. We also offer a variety of bakery goods such as muffins, pastries, donuts & more. Browse our Grab & Go case for conveniently pre made items and small grocery goods.  Enjoy your breakfast or lunch in our cafe or have your catering order delivered to your home or business.


free delivery

free delivery to local business with your order of $50.00 or more

featured in
Long Island Pulse Magazine: 
Long Island's 5 Best Sandwiches
10 Long Island Bagel Shops Not To Be Missed
10 Egg-Cellent Bacon, Egg, & Cheese Sandwiches
Quick LI Breakfast You'll Love
Mount Sinai Miller Place Rocky Point Shoreham
Macaroni Kids:
Macaroni Kids Daisy Award Best Bagels 





Better On A Bagel has been serving Miller Place & the surrounding communities for over 10 years.

We are known best for our soft, chewy bagels made from scratch daily. Find out more about us 

Fresh baked bagels, pastries, speciality cream cheeses, sandwiches with premium Boar's Head products, fresh brewed coffees, teas, & so much more.

Read our full menu here

Better On A Bagel Miller Place 

275 Route 25A  Miller Place, New York 11764

(631) 473-3030

Better On A Bagel Express Coram

25 Gibbs Road Coram, New York 11727

(631) 509-4884

Follow us on Facebook to enter our weekly giveaways for FREE food

& stay updated on promotions

& specials!